Montreal Metro still trying to replace ageing fleet
Montreal’s metro system is operated by the Société de Transport de Montréal (STM) and was first opened back in 1966, since then it has grown into one of the largest subways in the country and is the busiest in Canada with over 290 million trips taken on the system last year. The 759 trains that operate on the network are ageing and tired, having each carried an estimated 7900 people and plans are afoot to replace them.
Of the 759 or so vehicles in operation on the metro, around 300 of them have been STM’s workhorses since the 1960s and are among the oldest subway trains in the world, although the entire Montreal Metro remains one of the most reliable in North America, according to recent Montreal news reports.
Montreal news media reported in 2006 that there were 333 metro trains that STM wanted to have replaced. Initially, the company had decided to award the contract, worth around $1.9 billion, to Bombardier, the company that manufactured the MR-73s that run on the metro. Between 2006 and 2008 STM and Bombardier were in negotiations regarding cost controls, the specifications of the new trains and warranty issues.
However, a French company, Alstom, took legal action against STM for not carrying out a bidding process for the contract and in early 2008 Montreal news media reported that Quebec Superior Court Judge Joel Silcoff had ruled in Alstom’s favor. The company was therefore able to bid on the project, which delayed the expected date by which the new trains would be introduced to the metro.
However, the government of Quebec decided that it was in the interests of the public to open the bidding to international companies, such as CAF in Spain, the government contended that international bidding would provide the best price for STM, though the move was heavily opposed by Bombardier and Alstom and they instigated legal proceedings the same year, according to Montreal news reports.
However, in June of 2010, Quebec's Superior Court once more ruled that it was in the best interests of the public to allow CAF to bid as well. By this point, the future plans of STM had changed and the order value had increased to $3 billion, for the manufacture of 756 cars which would replace most of the current fleet. The deal also calls for the option to purchase a further 288 trains, in-line with STM’s significant expansion plans for the metro.
Bombardier's La Pocatière plant has been building M-7 electric multiple-unit commuter railcars for the Metropolitan Transit Authority in New York for the past several years, that project is now coming to an end and another big order is needed to keep the plant operating at its current capacity. For this reason, Bombardier has warned that it may need to layoff up to 185 staff if STM awards the contract to CAF.
The plane and train maker has further alleged that CAF will not be able to meet STM’s contractual demands, which call for 60% of all production to be carried out in Quebec.
“We find it incomprehensible that [CAF] meets the contract's demands,” Bombardier spokesperson Marc-André Lefebvre told Montreal news media. The company is headquartered in the city.
However, CAF spokesperson Philippe Roy has hit back saying that the Spanish company intends to build all the trains in Quebec. “We intend to open a plant in Quebec, create CAF Canada and do it all in Quebec,” he said, adding that the people of Montreal would now pay less for their new trains.
Meanwhile, STM has indicated that the ongoing bidding process may take a further several months, which may delay the production of new trains by up to two years.
Comments
More Montreal News
RSS-
Montreals boil water advisory lifted mayor says
A man crosses a street carrying litres of water as water pours out of a fire hydrant, in Montreal, Wednesday, May 22, 2013. (Paul Chiasson / THE CANADIAN ...
-
SNC-Lavalin sought Ottawas help to give Gadhafi’s son vice-president’s job
Canada's flagship engineering company hoped to persuade Ottawa officials to let a Libyan dicator's son come to Canada as a temporary foreign worker, newly unsealed court documents show.In 2008, Saadi Gadhafi, the 40-year-old son of Moammar Gadhafi, was being touted as a potential "Vice-President Maghreb" for SNC-Lavalin, with the multinational's executives stating that ...
-
Former premier among growing list of politicians offered cash in Laval
Radio-Canada's investigative program Enqute has discovered that the practice of offering cash-stuffed envelopes to politicians in Laval dates back decades, with former a PQ premier adding his personal story to the growing collection. Bernard Landry says in 1976, when he was the newly-elected MNA for the Laval riding of Fabre, an individual approached him with an envelope. "He said, ...
-
SNC-Lavalin letter says Gadhafi son offered VP post RCMP
Saadi Gaddafi, seen here speaking at his office in Tripoli in January 2010, was offered a three-year contract at a $150,000 annual salary, according to a letter seized by the RCMP from SNC-Lavalin headquarters in 2012. (Ismail ...
-
Roy returns to Colorado Avalanche as coach
Patrick Roy , who helped Colorado to two Stanley Cup titles as a goaltender, Thursday agreed in principle to become the Avalanche's next coach. Roy, 47, is a Hall of Fame goaltender who won the Stanley Cup in 1986 and 1993 while with the Montreal Canadiens and in 1996 and 2001 while playing for Colorado. "This is a very exciting day for our fans and a significant moment in our ...
-
Quebec woman run over three times by her own car
TROIS-RIVIERES, Que. -- A woman is recovering following a bizarre accident in which she was run over three times by her own car. Trois-Rivieres, Que., police say the newspaper delivery woman was making her rounds this week and jumping in and out of her car frequently to drop copies of Le Nouvelliste on subscribers' doorsteps. But things went awry during one parking attempt. Her ...
-
Quebec film wins screenplay prize at Cannes
a movie by Quebec director Sebastien Pilote, has won one of the main prizes of sidebar program Critics Week at the Cannes Film Festival. The film, which translates ...
-
Smog is back in Ottawa this spring
OTTAWA -- Smog is back in town after a four-year absence, a reminder that there are no quick and easy roads to clean air.As always, this air pollutant is a bit of a mystery.Ozone gas, the main ingredient in Eastern Canada's smog, forms when a variety of air pollutants react together in bright sunlight. It's mostly and spring and summer problem.But in the summer of 2009, it just stopped ...
-
More than one-third of Quebec high-schoolers victimized study
MONTREAL -- More than one in three high-school students in the province say they have been victims of violence at school or on the way to or from school, according to a study made public Thursday by the Institut de la statistique du Qubec. Just five per cent said they were victimized by cyberbullying during the school year, with girls nearly twice as likely to be bullied on the Internet as ...
-
UPDATE 1-Quebec to do own review of Enbridge pipeline project
Thu May 23, 2013 4:41pm EDT * Quebec to hold separate review of pipeline-reversal plan * Review to run concurrent to federal process By Valerie Volcovici WASHINGTON, May 23 (Reuters) - Quebec will announce within weeks that it will launch its own public review of a proposed pipeline that would deliver crude oil from western Canada to eastern markets, its environment minister said ...
-
TV importers accuse Ottawa of misleading tariff rulings
Importers of popular electronics such as big-screen TVs and MP3 players are ramping up their fight against federal tariff changes, accusing the government of misleading them by offering tariff breaks that it planned to claw back later.Importers of televisions are already on the hook for about $16-million in retroactive duties from 2011 after last year's crackdown on a particular tariff ...
-
Preview Cirque du Soleil’s ‘Michael Jackson One’ opens tonight at Mandalay Bay
Back in November 2011, it was the glittering gala for "Michael Jackson -- The Immortal World Tour," which has gone on to become the world's largest-grossing tour and this week is en route to Japan, then Australia, followed by China in August. Tonight, it's a different and unique new show, "Michael Jackson One," that opens in its first preview before the splashy June ...
-
Ottawa wins award for Canada’s most boring city
The Boring Awards committee has awarded Ottawa the title of most boring city in Canada, but it isn’t the city they mind so much as the ...
-
Boil-water advisory delay questioned by Montreal councillor
Updated Boil-water advisory to last until at least 10 p.m. Residents advised to boil water for at least 1 min. Largest boil-water advisory in Montreal's ...
-
CBCs Top Tweets Boil-water advisory
Most of Montreal has been under a boil-water advisory for more than 24-hours after dust sitting at the bottom of a resevoir mixed in with the water supply. ...
-
PQ polling woes continue
latest CROP survey in Thursday's La Presse. On the provincial side, it places support for Phillippe Couillard's Liberals at 38 per cent. That's 14 points ahead of the Parti Qubcois which is down to 24 per cent, only two points ahead of the Coalition Avenir Qubec which is polling at 22 per cent. Quebec Solidaire is at 10 per cent and Option Nationale up from three per cent to ...
-
Arctic bacteria found living in Mars-like environment
Scientists say they've found bacteria growing in the Canadian arctic at temperatures below freezing, nearly as cold as the surface of Mars. Growing at just 5 degrees Fahrenheit, the coldest temperature ever reported for bacterial growth, the bacterium offers clues about some of the necessary preconditions for microbial life on other worlds, such as Saturn's moon Enceladus and Mars, ...
-
Ottawa threatens ‘retaliatory measures’ over U.S. meat label rules
The federal government is threatening "retaliatory measures" against the United States in a dispute over meat-labelling rules that Ottawa and the World Trade Organization consider discriminatory.The U.S. government has announced new regulations on so-called country-of-origin labelling that would track beef and hogs through the meat processing and distribution ...
-
Ottawa gives new funding to child abuse centre named for Sheldon Kennedy
Former NHLer Sheldon Kennedy, left, speaks at a news conference with Justice Minister Rob Nicholson in Toronto on Monday, Feb. 4, 2013. (COLIN PERKEL/THE CANADIAN ...
-
Accused Via terror plotters make video appearance in court
A man charged in an alleged plot to bomb a Via Rail passenger train says he wants to be represented by a lawyer who agrees the Qur'an should be used as a "reference" in his case. Chiheb Esseghaier appeared in a Toronto court by video link this morning. He said he is seeking a legal aid lawyer to defend him against several terrorism-related charges in what the RCMP has called the ...
-
Four Quebec cops accused of trafficking drugs
A police vehicle is seen outside of a house in Montreal on May 23, 2013. (SYLVAIN DENIS/QMI Agency) MONTREAL - Two Montreal police officers and two other cops from a nearby suburb have been arrested on drug-trafficking charges. In addition to trafficking, Montreal constables Charles Lavallee and Amir El Alfy are accused of importing narcotics. Also charged are Maxime Marcotte and Olivier Roy, ...
-
UPAC raids Montreal city hall
MONTREAL -- Quebec's anti-corruption squad carried out another raid at Montreal city hall Thursday morning.The operation was "very discreet," said Anne-Frdrick Laurence, a spokesperson for the Unit permanente anti-corruption, with only "a handful" of officers involved.Sources at city hall confirmed investigators arrived before 9:30 a.m. and visited the clerk's ...
Montreal Digest
-
Montreal Metro still trying to replace ageing fleet
The Montreal Metro is ageing, or its trains are at least, with some of them over 60 years old this year, it’s high time for massive investment in an overhaul of the fleet, but the bidding process has been controversial and highly competitive, leading to delays, which it is hoped will provide a lower cost.
Montreal’s metro system is operated by the Société de Transport de Montréal (STM) and was first opened back in 1966, since then it has grown into one of the largest subways in the country and is the busiest in Canada with over 290 million trips taken on the system last year. The 759 trains that operate on the network are ageing and tired, having each carried an estimated 7900 people and plans are afoot to replace them. Read more
News from around our Network
